Friar Alfonso DĆ”vila presents a reflection where a letter from Tolkien and Saint Monica’s last words help us to live November 2nd with hope: to pray for our departed and to continue the good they sowed in us.
For a few weeks now, in my free time, I’ve been reading Tolkien’s letters. I’d like to say I’m much further along in the volume, but I’m taking it slowly. A few days ago, I found a letter that stayed with me all the way to the chapel. I kept thinking about it and ended up praying with it. As All Souls’ Day approached, those words made me think about friendship, the pain of farewell, and our hope of reuniting in God.
Tolkien and a friendship wounded by war
The letter is addressed to Geoffrey Smith and dated August 12, 1916. Tolkien had just learned of the death of his friend Rob Gilson at the Battle of the Somme. Both, along with Smith and Christopher Wiseman, had formed a small society during their years at King Edwardās School in Birmingham. They called it T. C. B. S., initials born from their habit of meeting for tea, sometimes secretly, in the school library and at Barrowās stores.
Among those conversations, a friendship grew, capable of awakening a vocation. They shared readings, encouraged each other to write, and dreamed of contributing something to the world. Tolkien recognized how much his own voice owed to those encounters. The trust of his friends had helped him discover something that, on his own, he might not have known how to express.
Now war had entered that circle, and one of the four had died. “My chief impression so far is that something has broken,” he confesses, as he tries to understand what remains of the task they had dreamed of together. He feels alone, poorer, and in need of his friends. He struggles to recognize himself as part of that small group that once felt complete.
The death of a loved one breaks something within our lives. It hurts not to be able to see them, not to hear their voice, not to tell them what has happened to us. The pending conversations and the plans we can no longer fulfill together also hurt. Faith accompanies that pain, sometimes with more questions than words.
That’s why I was moved to find, amidst Tolkien’s bewilderment, a hope: perhaps the task of those friends could continue, and God would entrust the part of the absent ones to the inspiration they had left in others. He still didn’t know how to move forward, but he resisted giving up everything they had received together.
The Faithful Departed: love that continues to bear fruit
Reading it, I thought about what we celebrate today, on All Souls’ Day. About how many things in our lives began with someone who has already died. A way of praying, the courage to make a decision, a vocation that someone else recognized before us. There are people whose trust continues to sustain us years after the last conversation.
We continue to respond, in some way, to what they gave us. We can transmit the faith they taught us, offer someone the patience they had with us, continue a task they left unfinished. Remembering them can also commit us: what we receive from them can become a good for others.
As I prayed with that letter, an idea, difficult to articulate in the face of absence, lingered: to view death from the perspective of victory. There is a paradox at the heart of our faith that we even dare to sing: “Victory, you shall reign. O cross, you shall save us!” How can an instrument of death give us life? How can we find life amidst pain and hope for life beyond death?
These are questions that weigh differently when farewell touches us closely. Speaking of victory is easy when one is well and absence is not tearing one apart inside. In the face of another person’s suffering, such words demand respect. There are moments when we can barely accompany, remain silent, and weep together.
But we continue to look at the cross. There, Christ loved to the extreme and, with his resurrection, opened a path for us that passes through death. That is why we can entrust an entire life to Him: the love given, the efforts, the fragilities, and all that remained unfinished. We can hope that His mercy will pronounce the final word on that life.
Perhaps we begin to understand victory when we recognize how much good can be born from a life given. Someone loved, sustained others, shared their faith. Their passage through the world continues to bear fruit. And our hope reaches even further: we trust that God can bring to fullness that life which we have known here amidst limits and farewells.
Saint Monica: remembering our departed before the altar
Saint Augustine recounts in Book IX of the Confessions a request his mother, Saint Monica, made to him and his brother during her last illness, shortly before she died:
āBury this body anywhere, and do not trouble yourselves with its care; only I ask that you remember me at the altar of the Lord, wherever you may be.ā (Confessions, IX, 11, 27).
Monica points them to a place where they can continue to carry her name: the altar of the Lord. There they can give thanks for her life and pray for her. Her request leaves her children something to do with the love they feel: to turn it into prayer.
Perhaps there we can learn to live our farewells. Pain occupies much space, and loss is felt in daily life. But remembrance can make its way to the altar. We can continue to love those who have died, entrusting them to God and hoping from Him what our hands can no longer give them.
To pray for the departed is to place their lives in the hands of mercy. To bring their names, their stories, and our gratitude to the Eucharist. To tell the Lord how much we love them and to ask Him to receive them into the fullness of His life.
This November 2nd, let us bring the names of our departed to the altar. Afterwards, let us return to our tasks with a question: what will we do with the love they left us?
We can still make it bear fruit. We can support someone, awaken hope, help another find their way. As Tolkien sensed in his pain, the shared task can continue in those of us who remain here.
And when our own hour comes, may we also have given something that others can continue. May they bring our names to the altar and continue walking with hope. Until the day God reunites us and we discover how much of that shared love was already opening the doors of eternity for us.












